2023 All-Star Nominations
| School | Boys Nominees | Status |
| CKHS | Payton Davis | |
| Kingston | Dakota Standley | |
| Kingston | Noah Walter | |
| Kingston | Cash Hubbard | |
| Kingston | Kah-ty Natrall | Alternate |
| Klahowya | Robbie Slater | |
| Klahowya | Joey Lancaster | Alternate |
| Olympic | Jaden Bluitt | |
| Olympic | Tristan Bluitt | |
| Olympic | Sean Clegg | |
| Olympic | Malakai Quinene | |
| Crosspoint | Ross Wohlert | |
| Crosspoint | Sam Dykstra | |
| NKHS | Jalen East | |
| NKHS | Ethan Gillespie | |
| NKHS | Jay Ashford-Downing | |
| Sequim HS | Isaiah Moore | |
| Sequim HS | Zack Thompson | |
| Sequim HS | Vince Carrizosa | |
| East Jefferson | Lorenzo McCleese | |
| East Jefferson | Michael Petta | Alternate |
| East Jefferson | Austen Hammer | Alternate |
| East Jefferson | Toby Fulton | Alternate |
| Bremerton | Sam Tucker | |
| Bainbridge | Cooper Benjamin | |
| Bainbridge | Caleb Durrance | |
| Bainbridge | Breno Oguri | |
| School | Girls Nominees | Status |
| CKHS | Jada Kopp | |
| CKHS | Sahara Soufi | |
| CKHS | Sophie Driskell | |
| CKHS | Ella Baumgartner | |
| SKHS | Aly Loudermilk | |
| Port Angeles | Piper Williams | |
| Port Angeles | Anna Petty | |
| Olympic | Kylee Murphy | |
| Olympic | Angelina Godinez-Gonzalez | |
| Olympic | Brookelynn Hartford | |
| Olympic | Mailli Bode | |
| Crosspoint | Konami Nozawa | |
| Crosspoint | Ashlyn Keller | |
| NKHS | Sophia Baugh | |
| NKHS | Jade Sunnenberg | |
| Sequim HS | Samantha Bacon | |
| Sequim HS | Jelissa Julmist | |
| Sequim HS | Hannah Bates | |
| Bremerton | Tulip Carter | |
| Bremerton | Promise Bell | |
| Bainbridge | Elsa Cajune | |
| Bainbridge | Ghadir Ramadan |
